Información jurídica inteligente
 México | +52 (55) 416 971 36

La lógica centralizadora del Sistema Federal Mexicano

Document Citado por Relacionados
Vincent
AutorJosé Ma. Serna de la Garza
Cargo del AutorProfesor-Investigador, Instituto de Investigaciones Jurídicas, UNAM
Páginas573-605
— 573 —
6NR¥8A$!
(/7E561/139?=/76C/2:=/237>6>?38/
4323=/783A61/9:##
,-)#+'*":&=KPX[VKMSgWNOU¥S¥]OVK&::&=KPg[V^UKNONS¥%
][SL^MSgWNOMXVYO]OWMSK¥&:::&6UO¥Z^OVKNOUK¥[OUKMSXWO¥
kpvgt/iwdgtpcogpvcngu0"KX0"Gn"hgfgtcnkuoq"Þuecn"ogzkecpq0"X0"
6UYXNO[NOMOUOL[K[][K]KNX¥SW]O[WKMSXWKUO¥ aOU¥S¥]OVK
PONO[KU&G:&4XWMU^¥SXWO¥&G::&3SLUSXQ[KPeK&
'!(/4:=8/16E9237>6>?38/
=KPX[VKPONO[KUNO6¥]KNX¥OKNXY]KOWW^O¥][XYKe¥NO¥NOUX¥X[eQOWO¥VS¥%
VX¥NOW^O¥][K̲SNKMXVX6¥]KNX%WKMSgWSWNOYOWNSOW]O&6¥]XO¥$¥SOW'.('¥O
MXW¥^VKUKSWNOYOWNOWMSKNO6¥YKfK$OW'.(*¥^[QOUKY[SVO[KMXW¥]S]^MSgW
ogzkecpc."okuoc"swg"cfqrv„"nc"hqtoc"hgfgtcn0'
6WOUKQS]KNX¥SQUX"""ogzkecpq."nc"ewguvk„p"fg"nc"hqtoc"hgfgtcn"hwg"wp"vg%
VKNO̲SXUOW]KNS¥Y^]K&6W'.),$YX[ OTOVYUX$¥OKNXY]g^WKMXW¥]S]^MSgWNO
MX[]OMOW][KUS¥]KZ^OKLXUSgOUO¥Z^OVKPONO[KU&DSWOVLK[QX$OW'.+-OUPONO[K%
US¥VX̲XU̲SgYX[¥^¥P^O[X¥$MXWUK4XW¥]S]^MSgWNO'.+-&AX¥]O[SX[VOW]O$MXW
nc"kpvgtxgpek„p"pcrqng„pkec"{"gn"Korgtkq"fg"Oczkoknkcpq."ug"xqnxk„"c"cdqnkt"gn"
#A[XPO¥X[%:W̲O¥]SQKNX[$:W¥]S]^]XNO:W̲O¥]SQKMSXWO¥;^[eNSMK¥$F?2>&:VYK[]OUK¥VK]O[SK¥NO/
EOX[eKNOUK4XW¥]S]^MSgW$5O[OMRXMXW¥]S]^MSXWKUMXVYK[KNX$6¥]KNXNO5O[OMRXa4XW¥]S]^MSgW$O
Jkuvqtkc"fgn"eqpuvkvwekqpcnkuoq"ogzkecpq."fgpvtq"fg"nqu"rtqitcocu"fg"ocguvtc"{"fkrnqocfqu"fgn"KKL0"
##=KVKaX[YK[]ONOUY[O¥OW]OOW¥KaXPX[VKYK[]OVSUSL[X1KMAMZ#
KIRIRJTQ]DICN."WPCO."Ofizkeq."422:0"Gp"wpc"xgtuk„p"rtgnkokpct."crctgek„"gp"Xcncffiu."Fkgiq"{"Ugtpc."
;X¥d>K&!MXX[N¥&"$2EDEQAKIRLNX;EGINMAKIRLN."WPCO."Ofizkeq."42270
'5^[KW]OUKhU]SVKO]KYKNOUKMXUXWSK$¥O NSO[XW^WK¥O[SONOMKVLSX¥KNVSWS¥][K]S̲X¥Z^O
hwgtqp"gn"igtogp"fg"nq"swg"cjqtc"uqp"ncu"gpvkfcfgu"hgfgtcvkxcu"ogzkecpcu0"Ncu" tghqtocu"dqtd„pk%
ecu"fg"Þpcngu"fgn"ukinq""!M[OK[XWUK¥SW]OWNOWMSK¥$Z^O[O¥YXWNeKWK^WK[OPX[VKKNVSWS¥][K]S̲K
Z^OK][K̲d¥NOMSO[]KNO¥MOW][KUSbKMSgWY[O]OWNeKVOTX[K[OUVKWOTXNOUK¥MXUXWSK¥ NO6¥YKfKOW
Cofitkec0"Rquvgtkqtogpvg."dclq"nc"xkigpekc"fg"nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p"fg"Eƒfk¦."ug"etg„"nc"Þiwtc"fg"ncu"Ñfk%
Y^]KMSXWO¥Y[X̲SWMSKUO¥lZ^O]KVLSdWMXW][SL^aO[XWKS[PX[VKWNX^WKSNOW]SNKNYXUe]SMKY[XYSK
a^WO¥YKMSXNO]XVKNONOMS¥SXWO¥K^]gWXVXNOU MOW][X&2UXM^[[S[UK[^Y]^[KNO6¥YKfK$O¥K¥
hwgt¦cu"nqecngu"eqdtctqp"hwgt¦c"{"gzkikgtqp"eqoq"eqpfkek„p"rctc"rgtocpgegt"fgpvtq"fg"wp"okuoq"
6¥]KNX%WKMSgW$UK7X[VK7ONO[KU&
&*,.("!,$+)"#$'"%"+-"
— 574 —
PONO[KUS¥VX$VS¥VXZ^O[O¥^[QSgMXWUK[OSW¥]K^[KMSgWNOUKCOYhLUSMKaNOUK
4XW¥]S]^MSgWNO'.+-$OW'.,-&
HKOWOU¥SQUX""."fgurwfiu"fg"nc"Tgxqnwek„p"ogzkecpc"*3;32/3;39+"ug"gzrkfk„"
nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p"fg"3;39."vqfcxc"xkigpvg"gp"Ofizkeq"gn"fc"fg"jq{."uk"dkgp"eqp"wp"
¥SWWhVO[XNO[OPX[VK¥&5SMRKMXW¥]S]^MSgW[OYS]OOWQOWO[KUUK¥MK[KM]O[e¥]SMK¥
NOUO¥Z^OVKPONO[KUNOUK4XW¥]S]^MSgWNO'.+-&6¥NOMS[$O¥]KLUOMO^W¥S¥]OVK
hgfgtcn"dcucfq"gp"ÑGuvcfquÒ"{"wp"ÑFkuvtkvq"HgfgtcnÒ"*tgukfgpekc"fg"nqu"rqfgtgu"
PONO[KUO¥"&("Cukokuoq."nqu"Guvcfqu"iq¦cp"fg"wp"tfiikogp"fg"cwvqpqoc"fgÞpkfc"
OW]d[VSWX¥NOUSLO[]KNa¥XLO[KWeKOW]XNXUXZ^OMXWMSO[WOK¥^[dQSVOWSW%
]O[SX[&)4XVXVKWSPO¥]KMSgWNONSMRKK^]XWXVeK$MKNK6¥]KNX]SOWOUKPKM^U]KN
NOO¥]KLUOMO[¥^¥Y[XYSX¥g[QKWX¥NOQXLSO[WXOTOM^]S̲X$UOQS¥UK]S̲XaT^NSMSKU
!NOW][XNOUX¥UeVS]O¥Z^OVK[MKUK4XW¥]S]^MSgW8OWO[KU$OWYK[]SM^UK[OUK[]e%
M^UX'',"&2NOVc¥$OU¥S¥]OVKNONS¥][SL^MSgWNOMXVYO]OWMSK¥¥OLK¥KOW^WK
enƒwuwnc"tgukfwcn"gp"hcxqt"fg"nqu"Guvcfqu"*ÑCtvewnq"3460"Ncu"hcewnvcfgu"swg"pq"
guvƒp"gzrtgucogpvg"eqpegfkfcu"rqt"guvc"Eqpuvkvwek„p"c"nqu"hwpekqpctkqu"hgfg%
[KUO¥$¥OOW]SOWNOW[O¥O[̲KNK¥KUX¥6¥]KNX¥l"& AX[X][XUKNX$UK4XW¥]S]^MSgW
̲SQOW]OMXW]OVYUK^WYXNO[UOQS¥UK]S̲XPONO[KULSMKVO[KU$MXW^WK4cVK[KNO
Fkrwvcfqu"{"wp"Ugpcfq0"Cukokuoq."nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p"fg"3;39"rtgxfi"wp"glgewvkxq"
PONO[KU^WSYO[¥XWKU$OUOQSNXYX[¥^P[KQSX^WS̲O[¥KUaNS[OM]X0a^WYXNO[T^NSMSKU
PONO[KUMXVY^O¥]XYX[UKD^Y[OVK4X[]ONO;^¥]SMSK$OUE[SL^WKU6UOM]X[KUNOU
AXNO[;^NSMSKUNOUK7ONO[KMSgW$UX¥][SL^WKUO¥NOMS[M^S]XaUX¥T^bQKNX¥NONS¥%
vtkvq0"Hkpcnogpvg."nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p"fg"3;39"guvcdngeg"rqt"rtkogtc"xg¦"gp"gn"eqpuvk%
vwekqpcnkuoq"ogzkecpq."wpc"dcug"eqpuvkvwekqpcn"gurgeÞec"uqdtg"nc"qticpk¦cek„p"
V^WSMSYKU!K[]eM^UX''+"&
Gp"nc"cevwcnkfcf."Ofizkeq"ewgpvc"eqp"53"Guvcfqu"{"3"Fkuvtkvq"Hgfgtcn0"Nqu"53"
6¥]KNX¥]SOWOWUKVS¥VKWK]^[KUObKaOUVS¥VXO¥]K]^]XMXW¥]S]^MSXWKU&6U5S¥][S%
]X7ONO[KU]SOWO^WO¥]K]^]XMXW¥]S]^MSXWKUY[XYSXaNS¥]SW]XNOUNOUX¥6¥]KNX¥&
Rqt"qvtq"ncfq."gzkuvgp"4.64;"Owpkekrkqu."ew{c"eqpÞiwtcek„p"lwtfkeq/eqpuvkvw%
MSXWKUO¥UKVS¥VKYK[K]XNX¥$KYO¥K[NOZ^O¥^[OKUSNKN¥XMSKU$OMXWgVSMKa
M^U]^[KUO¥¥^VKVOW]ONS̲O[¥K&
2RX[KLSOW$KYO¥K[NOUKO¥][^M]^[KPONO[KUZ^OKMKLXNONO¥M[SLS[OW¥^¥
npgcu"oƒu"igpgtcngu."gn"ukuvgoc"hgfgtcn"ogzkecpq"cewuc"wp"cnvq"itcfq"fg"egp%
][KUSbKMSgW&6UUX¥ONOLO$OWQ[KWVONSNK$KZ^OOU¥S¥]OVKYXUe]SMXPX[VKNXOW
Ofizkeq"c"nq"nctiq"fgn"ukinq"""$]^̲XMXVXYSObKP^WNKVOW]KU^WKY[O¥SNOWMSKNO
UKCOYhLUSMK¥^VKVOW]OP^O[]O$Z^OKYK[]S[NO^W¥S¥]OVKNOYK[]SNXROQOVg%
pkeq"fgucttqnn„"{"eqpuqnkf„"nc"ecrcekfcf"fg"glgtegt"wpc"kpàwgpekc"fgvgtokpcpvg"
WX¥XUKVOW]O¥XL[OUKYXUe]SMKUXMKU$¥SWX¥XL[OOU4XWQ[O¥XNOUKFWSgWaRK¥]K
UKD^Y[OVK4X[]ONO;^¥]SMSK&3KTXO¥]K¥MS[M^W¥]KWMSK¥$KYO¥K[NOUKPKMRKNKPX[%
VKUVOW]OPONO[KU$UKYXUe]SMK[OKU¥OMXWN^TXNO^WKVKWO[KMOW][KUSbKNK&2¥S%
("Jcuvc"3;96"jwdq"vcodkfip"ÑVgttkvqtkquÒ"hgfgtcngu."swg"cjqtc"uqp"gpvkfcfgu"hgfgtcvkxcu0
)"Ctvewnqu"62"{"63"fg"nc"Eqpuvkvwek„p"Igpgtcn0
— 575 —
(!(1&'"!"$*.,!('/!#+,!#$(-'-.$)!%$#$,!(
VS¥VX$NSMRX¥S¥]OVK¥OOWMK[QgNOSW][XN^MS[OWOUNS¥OfXSW¥]S]^MSXWKUPONO[KU
NOW^O¥][XYKe¥$^WKUgQSMKMOW][KUSbKNX[K$YX[VONSXNOUKM^KU¥OMXW¥XUSNgUK
¥^LX[NSWKMSgWNOUX¥6¥]KNX¥KUX¥YXNO[O¥PONO[KUO¥$aOWYK[]SM^UK[$KUKSW¥]S%
]^MSgWNOUKY[O¥SNOWMSKNOUKCOYhLUSMK&6¥KUgQSMKO¥UKZ^OWX¥Y[XYXWOVX¥
KWKUSbK[OWOUY[O¥OW]O][KLKTX&
DX¥]OWOVX¥Z^OO¥WOMO¥K[SXNO¥M^L[S[NSMRKUgQSMK$YK[KKYK[]S[NOKRe][K%
¦ct"ncu"npgcu"fg"nc"tghqtoc"rqukdng0"Pq"ecdg"fwfc"swg"gn"ukuvgoc"hgfgtcn"ogzkec%
pq."gp"uw"eqpÞiwtcek„p"eqpuvkvwekqpcn"{"ngicn."tgswkgtg"fg"tghqtocu"korqtvcpvgu0"
6UKW]SQ^X¥S¥]OVKYXUe]SMXMOW][KUSbKNX[aKM^¥KNKVOW]OY[O¥SNOWMSKUS¥]KaNO
YK[]SNXROQOVgWSMX¥ORKSNXO̲KYX[KWNX&6W¥^U^QK[RKSNX ¥^[QSOWNXNO
VKWO[KUOW]K$aK̲OMO¥]eVSNK$^W¥S¥]OVKW^O̲X$OWOUZ^OUX¥NS¥]SW]X¥KM]X[O¥
YXUe]SMX¥a¥XMSKUO¥$[OMUKVKWW^O̲X¥O¥YKMSX¥NOYK[]SMSYKMSgWaNONOMS¥SgW&
2W]OO¥]KMS[M^W¥]KWMSK$OUNS¥OfXSW¥]S]^MSXWKUNOU¥S¥]OVKPONO[KUWXY^ONO
YO[VKWOMO[KWMUKNXKUKKW]SQ^KUgQSMKMOW][KUSbKNX[K&2UMXW][K[SX$NOLOVX¥
SNOK[Pg[V^UK¥WX̲ONX¥K¥YK[K¥KUS[NONSMRKUgQSMK$KOPOM]XNOOW][K[OW^WK
fkpƒokec"swg"rgtokvc"xkvcnk¦ct"c"nqu"Guvcfqu"{"c"nqu"Owpkekrkqu"fg"Ofizkeq0"
Nqu"ogzkecpqu"fg"jq{"guvcoqu"cpvg"nc"vctgc"gpqtog"fg"gpeqpvtct"wp"fkug‚q"
SW¥]S]^MSXWKUZ^ONO̲^OU̲KPKM^U]KNO¥KUX¥6¥]KNX¥aKUX¥>^WSMSYSX¥$YO[XZ^O
]KVLSdWQOWO[OUK¥MXWNSMSXWO¥YK[KUXQ[K[UKMXRO[OWMSKOWOUKM]^K[YhLUSMX&
5OLOVX¥OWMXW][K[^WY^W]XNOOZ^SUSL[SXSW¥]S]^MSXWKUZ^O]XVOOWM^OW]KUK¥
itcpfgu"fkhgtgpekcu"swg"gzkuvgp"gpvtg"Guvcfqu"{"gpvtg"Owpkekrkqu."{"swg"c"nc"xg¦"
]SOWNKKQK[KW]SbK[^WVeWSVX¥K]S¥PKM]X[SXNO¥O[̲SMSX¥aLSOWO¥YhLUSMX¥YK[K
]XNX¥UX¥Z^O̲S̲SVX¥OWO¥]OYKe¥&
AK[KMXW][SL^S[OWO¥]K]K[OK$OUO¥Z^OVKNOUY[O¥OW]O][KLKTX¥ORKNS̲SNSNX
OWM^K][XYK[]O¥$[OUK]S̲K¥K/UKPg[V^UKNONS¥][SL^MSgWNOMXVYO]OWMSK¥0UK¥
tgncekqpgu"fg"eqncdqtcek„p="gn"hgfgtcnkuoq"Þuecn"{"gn"rqfgt"fg"egngdtct"vtcvcfqu"
SW]O[WKMSXWKUO¥&6WOUUK¥VOY[XYXWQXKWKUSbK[UKUgQSMKMOW][KUSbKNX[KKUKZ^O
jg"jgejq"tghgtgpekc."rctc"c"rctvkt"fg"cj"vtcvct"fg"kfgpvkÞect"ncu"xcu"rqt"ncu"swg"
ug"rqftc"cxcp¦ct"gp"nc"tgxkvcnk¦cek„p"fgn"ukuvgoc"hgfgtcn"ogzkecpq0
''!(/4E=8@7/2326>?=60@16E9231:8;3?3916/>
Nc"ocvtk¦"fgn"ukuvgoc"fg"fkuvtkdwek„p"fg"eqorgvgpekcu"fgn"ukuvgoc"hgfgtcn"ogzk%
MKWX¥OOWM^OW][KOWUKMUc^¥^UK[O¥SN^KUKPK̲X[NOUX¥6¥]KNX¥$MXW]OWSNKOWOU
K[]eM^UX'(*NOUK4XW¥]S]^MSgW&GS¥]KNOVKWO[KKS¥UKNK$UKPg[V^UKNOUK[]eM^UX
'(*MXW¥]S]^MSXWKUO¥]KLUOMO^W¥S¥]OVKQ]GIDNNONS¥][SL^MSgWNOMXVYO]OWMSK¥&
Ugi¿p"fkejc"h„townc."vrkec"fgn"oqfgnq"swg"nc"fqevtkpc"fgpqokpc"Ñhgfgtcnkuoq"
fwcnÒ."rctgekgtc"swg"ug"eqpÞiwtc"wp"ukuvgoc"gp"gn"swg"fg"ocpgtc"enctc"ug"rwg%
NONO]O[VSWK[Z^O^WKMXVYO]OWMSKMX[[O¥YXWNOaK¥OKKUKPONO[KMSgWXKUK¥
gpvkfcfgu"hgfgtcvkxcu0"Fkejc"tkikfg¦"fgtkxc."eqoq"ug"jc"gzrnkecfq"rqt"fkxgtuqu"
cwvqtgu."fg"nc"wvknk¦cek„p"swg"gp"fkejq"ctvewnq"ug"jceg"fgn"cfxgtdkq"Ñgzrtguc%

Para continuar leyendo

Solicita tu prueba
Índice de navegación

Búsquedas relacionadas:

VLEX utiliza cookies de inicio de sesión para aportarte una mejor experiencia de navegación. Si haces click en 'Aceptar' o continúas navegando por esta web consideramos que aceptas nuestra política de cookies. ACEPTAR